Simple Switch

Biodegradable vs Compostable: What's the Difference?

By the Simple Switch Editorial Team · Updated November 16, 2026

Woman adding food scraps to a backyard compost bin

"Biodegradable" means something can be broken down by natural processes eventually, but it doesn't say how long that takes or under what conditions. "Compostable" is more specific: it means a product can break down into compost under composting conditions. The catch is that many products labeled compostable are designed for industrial composting facilities, not backyard bins, so whether they actually get composted depends on what your area accepts.

This is one of the most confusing label questions in our Green Products section, and getting it right can keep good intentions from ending up in the wrong bin.

Biodegradable: a broad and often vague word

Almost everything breaks down eventually given enough time. That's why "biodegradable" on its own says very little. A product could take a very long time to break down, need specific conditions or break into smaller pieces rather than turn into soil.

The FTC's Green Guides say environmental claims should be specific and backed by evidence, and they treat broad, unqualified claims as likely to mislead. For "biodegradable," that means a seller should be able to explain what breaks down, in what setting and in what time frame. Our guide to spotting greenwashing explains how the Green Guides work in general.

Questions to ask about a biodegradable claim:

  • Biodegradable where? In a landfill, in water, in soil or in a compost facility?
  • How long does it take?
  • Does it fully break down, or just break into small pieces?
  • Is the whole product biodegradable, or only part?

Compostable: more specific, but read the details

A compostable product is designed to break down along with food scraps and yard waste into compost. There are two main settings:

  • Industrial composting facilities run large, managed piles that reach higher temperatures and are turned and monitored. Many compostable cups, cutlery, bags and food containers are designed for these facilities.
  • Home composting happens in backyard bins, tumblers and piles, which are usually cooler and slower. Fewer products are designed to break down well in these conditions.

Many products labeled compostable are made for industrial composting, not backyard bins. If you put an industrial-compostable fork in a home bin, you might find it there, mostly intact, many months later.

What BPI certification means

The Biodegradable Products Institute (BPI) certifies products as compostable in industrial facilities. Its mark tells you the product has been reviewed against standards for breaking down in commercial composting, not that it will break down in your yard.

How to use the BPI mark:

  1. Look for the mark itself, not just the word "compostable." Certified items usually carry the BPI logo, and you can search BPI's public list of certified products.
  2. Know what it covers. BPI certification is about industrial composting facilities.
  3. Check your local program. Even certified products only get composted if a facility near you accepts them. Some facilities accept food scraps but not packaging.
  4. Follow local sorting rules. Your city or hauler's website often lists exactly what goes in a compost cart.

Quick comparison

TermWhat it meansWhere it breaks downWhat to check
BiodegradableBreaks down by natural processes at some pointUnclear without more detailWhere, how long and whether it fully breaks down
Industrial compostableBreaks down in managed commercial facilitiesIndustrial compostingCertification such as BPI, and whether your area accepts it
Home compostableDesigned to break down in a home binBackyard bins and pilesA clear home-compostable claim and a certification you can look up
RecyclableCan be collected and processed into new materialRecycling facilitiesWhether your local program accepts it

Where compostable products should go

Compostable products don't fit neatly anywhere if your area has no program for them.

  • If you have a local compost program that accepts them: put them in the compost cart, following local rules.
  • If you have a home bin and the product is home compostable: cut it into small pieces and mix it in well.
  • If neither applies: they usually go in the trash. Don't put compostable plastics in the recycling bin, because they can look like regular plastic and cause sorting problems.

Our guide to composting food scraps explains how backyard bins, worm bins and municipal pickup work. For plastics, our guide to what recycling numbers mean explains why a number doesn't make something recyclable where you live.

Where you'll see these claims most

  • Takeout containers, cups and cutlery: often industrial compostable.
  • Trash and dog waste bags: claims vary widely; see our guide to eco-friendly pet products.
  • Toothbrushes and personal care tools: some have bamboo handles with nylon bristles, which are rarely compostable as a whole. Our guide to green personal care covers this.
  • Bamboo products: wood-like bamboo items and bamboo fabric are very different; our bamboo products guide explains the tradeoffs.
  • Furniture and home goods: natural materials may break down eventually, but finishes and glues change that. See our guide to furniture that lasts.

Reuse still comes first

A compostable cup is a nice upgrade from some disposables, but it's still single use. Where you can, choose a reusable mug, container or utensil set. Save compostables for times when reusables aren't practical, like a large event where your area has a compost program.

Worked example: hosting a backyard party

Example: Taylor, in their early forties, is hosting a cookout for twenty people and plans to buy compostable plates and cutlery. Before ordering, they check their city's compost program and learn it accepts food scraps but not compostable plates or forks.

Taylor changes the plan: they borrow extra plates and silverware from a neighbor, set out a dish tub for used cutlery and put a bin labeled "food scraps" next to the trash. The compostable items stay on the shelf for another time.

Something to do this weekend

Look up your city or trash hauler's website and find out three things: whether food scraps are collected, whether compostable packaging is accepted and where compostable items should go if not. Write the answers on a sticky note near your trash and recycling bins so everyone in the household can check.

Partner offer · paid placement

Want a step-by-step plan or guide?

Some people like the structure of a paid guide or set of plans. This button opens a third-party program from one of our advertising partners. Its claims are its own, not ours, so weigh them against our checklist for judging paid plans.

See the partner program →

We may be paid when you click. The program shown can change. Read its terms before you buy anything. How this works

Frequently asked questions

Can I put compostable products in my backyard compost bin?

Usually not, unless the product says it's made for home composting. Many compostable products are designed for industrial facilities that run hotter and are more carefully managed than a backyard pile.

What does BPI certified mean?

The Biodegradable Products Institute (BPI) certifies products as compostable in industrial composting facilities. A BPI mark tells you the product is meant for that kind of facility, not necessarily for a home bin.

Should compostable products go in the recycling bin?

No. Compostable plastics can look like regular plastic but don't belong in most recycling bins, where they can cause problems. If your area doesn't accept them in a compost program, they usually go in the trash.

See a partner guidePartner offer
Partner offer · paid placement

Want a step-by-step guide?

If you'd like more structure than articles can give, you can look at a third-party guide or set of plans from one of our partners. Its claims are its own. No pressure: our free guides aren't going anywhere.

See the partner program →

We may be paid when you click. How this works